Catering Menu

Half trays serve 8-10 portions and large party platters serve 15-20 portions

All catering orders must be verified and confirmed by phone

Pick up | Drop off-delivery | Delivery and set-up service

Whether your event is a football party, kids birthday, or a business event, know that we will make every effort to deliver a well-planned and delicious experience, that is on time, on budget and successful. Or goal is to keep everyone happy -both you and your guests!

Our manager will work with you personally and be your “go to” person for all your event needs. We make it easy to place an order by phone or email. Our party trays can be customized to meet your preferences and budget.

Catering Loyalty Program

When you order through our catering manager, you will receive $20 back in Cosimo’s Gift Cards every time you spend $500 …ask Enzo for details.
Contact Enzo Mandarano at Direct: 215-242-9900 Email: emandarano@cosimospizzacafe.com

No matter how big or small we will handle it all!

From a business lunch for 10 to a birthday party for 200, we are your go-to party tray caterer in Chestnut Hill and the surrounding areas. You choose Pickup, Drop Off-Delivery, or Delivery with Set Up and we take it from there.

We offer a variety of service and menu options to accommodate all your catering needs. You can choose right off our Party Tray menu or if you need help with selections, our management staff will help you create a menu to make everyone happy. From vegetarians to gluten free diners, we can help you navigate all the dietary preferences to make your event a tasty success for everyone.

If there is something you want that is not listed, just ask and we’ll do our best to make modifications for you 24 hour advance notice is preferred, but we will do our best to accommodate same day events.

Snacks and Appetizers

Grilled Veggie Platter serves 8-12 $55.00

Beautifully displayed, Grilled seasonal veggies, fresh herbs, garlic, virgin oil

Chicken Tenders $45.00

House-made, crispy tenders with your choice of sauce

Mozzarella Bombs (50 pieces) $50.00

House-made, triple battered mozzarella

Garlic Knots (40 pieces) $25.00

Fresh baked in our oven with fresh garlic, Parmigiano and herbs

Rice Balls (20 pieces) $45.00

Arborio rice, peas, mozzarella, Parmigiano, herbs and plum tomato sauce

Herb Roasted Potatoes serves 8-12 $45.00

Made with Toasted garlic, fresh herbs and virgin olive oil

Sautéed Spinach serves 8-12 $45.00

with Toasted garlic, and virgin olive oil

Sweet ‘n’ Spicy Shrimp serves 8-12 p $65.00

Crispy Fried Shrimp tossed with our house-made sweet chili glaze and served over field greens

Loaded Cowboy Fries serves 8-12 $50.00

Crispy natural cut fries, with smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, scallions, and ranch dressing.

Wings (50 pieces) serves 8-12 $70.00

Perfectly crispy wings with your choice of sauce served with celery, carrots and blue cheese dressing

Hoagie Platters

Italian Party Hoagie Platter (serves 8-12) $75.00

Fresh sliced cured meats, provolone, lettuce & tomato, served with sweet peppers, hot peppers & onion on the side

Roast Turkey Hoagie Platter $75.00

Fresh sliced oven roasted turkey, American cheese, lettuce & tomato, served with sweet peppers, hot peppers & onion on the side

Mixed Hoagie Platter $75.00

Assorted hoagies of your choice, with lettuce & tomato, served with sweet peppers, hot peppers & onion on the side

Our Signature Round Party Hoagie (serves 8-12) $75.00

Our House-baked round bread filled with your choice of hoagie and fixings on the side

Baked Stromboli Platters

Fresh Baked Stromboli Platter (serves 8-12) $65.00

Your choice of any 3 ingredients to be combined with mozzarella cheese

Salad Platters

California Cobb (serves 8-12) $50.00

Hard Boiled Egg, Avocado, Tomato, Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, Bacon, Creamy Blue Cheese Dressing. Add Chicken 14.95 or Shrimp 24.95

Simple House Salad $35.00

Caesar Romano Salad $35.00

Gorgonzola Walnut Salad $45.00

Mixed Greens, Cranberries, Candied Walnuts, Gorgonzola, Roasted Red Pepper Dressing

Chef’s Chop Chop $50.00

Ham, Turkey, Provolone, Tomatoes, Gorgonzola, Olives, Bacon, with Balsamic Vinaigrette

Signature Pasta

Baked Rigatoni (serves 8-12) $50.00

With plum tomato sauce, herbed ricotta, Romano cheese, melted mozzarella, garlic bread, side salad, and your choice of dressing.

Spaghetti with Mini Meatballs (serves 8-12) $50.00

With plum tomato sauce, and house-made mini meatballs

Cheese Ravioli (serves 8-12) $60.00

Oven Baked, herbed ricotta and perorino romano stuffed ravioli with plum tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

Shrimp Mac ‘n’ Cheese (serves 8-12) $70.00

Our creamy cheese blend, crispy bacon and Parmigiano grattinata

Penne with Plum Tomato Sauce (serves 8-12) $40.00

Simple plum tomato sauce tossed with penne pasta and finished with grated Pecorino Romano

Penne with Grilled Chicken and Broccoli (serves 8-12) $50.00

Toasted Garlic and Virgin Olive oil, with sun-dried tomatoes, fresh broccoli and grilled chicken

Italian Sausage with Broccoli & Garlic (serves 8-12) $55.00

Penne Pasta tossed with toasted garlic and virgin olive oil, fresh broccoli and Italian sausage

Lasagna della Casa (serves 8-12) $65.00

Slow cooked all beef Bolognese, layered with pasta sheets, ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino romano

Signature Entrees and Specialties

Eggplant Rollatini (serves 8-12) $55.00

Battered eggplant, herb ricotta, mozzarella, pesto and plum tomato sauce baked in our oven

Chicken Marsala (serves 8-12) $55.00

Pan seared chicken, fresh herbs and marsala mushroom sauce

Parmesans (serves 8-12) $55.00

Your Choice of Eggplant Parmigiano

Chicken Parmigiano (serves 12) $70.00

Shrimp Parmigiano $80.00

Lemon Chicken (serves 8-12) $55.00

Sauteed chicken, fresh lemon, white wine and capers butter

Simple Grilled Chicken and Broccoli (serves 8-12) $55.00

Toasted garlic, virgin olive oil, fresh herbs

Meatballs (serves 8-12) $55.00

Pork and beef blend meatballs, slow roasted in our ovens

Sausage & Peppers (serves 8-12) $55.00

Italian Sausage, fresh cut sautéed peppers and onion

Desserts and Sweet Treats

House-baked Chocolate Chip Cookies (25 pieces) serves 8-12 $30.00

Big Brownie Platter (serves 8-12) $40.00

Mini Cannoli Platter (24 pieces) serves 8-12 $40.00

Zeppoli Basket serves 8-12 $30.00

Crispy zeppoli topped with cinnamon sugar and caramel

Miscellaneous

Sternos $4.00

Water Pans $3.00

Wire Racks $10.00

Cup of Plum Tomato Sauce (16 oz) $6.00

Cup of Shaved Parm Cheese (16 oz) $15.00

Individually Prepared Meals

Cosimo’s Lunch Box $12.95

Individually Wrapped Sandwich box
Your choice of hoagie with a pickle, seasonal fruit, chips and cookie

* 10 person minimum required
* Please let us know if anyone in your party is Vegetarian, Vegan or Gluten Free

Your Choice of Half-Hoagie

Italian Hoagie
Turkey & American
Roast Beef & Cheddar
Grilled Veggie (V) (grilled seasonal veggies, provolone & pesto mayo)
Tuna & Cheese
Three Cheese Hoagie (V)
Crispy Chicken Americano (crispy chicken, American cheese, let, tom, roasted garlic aioli)
Aegean Chicken Sandwich (grilled chicken, tom, cucumber, feta cheese, olives & lemon herb dressing)

Add Beverage to any order

Bottled Water 1.75
Pelligrino Soda 2.35
Assorted Pure Leaf Tea 2.95

Cosimo’s Entree Box $16.95

Individually boxed entrees
Your choice of Entree, includes pasta, seasonal veggie, garlic bread, and cookie for dessert.